The Mid-Year Youth Ministry Check-In: What’s Working & What Needs to Change?

Believe it or not, we’re already halfway through 2025. For youth pastors, that means two things: You’ve seen some incredible ministry wins. And you’ve also hit some frustrating roadblocks. The middle of the year isn’t just a checkpoint—it’s an opportunity. Before the fall semester kicks off, take some time to reflect, refocus, and recalibrate your approach. This mid-year youth ministry check-in will help you evaluate what’s working, what needs to change, and how to finish the year strong.

1. What’s Been Your Biggest Ministry Win So Far?

Before jumping into what needs fixing, start by celebrating what’s gone well.

Reflection Questions:

What has been the biggest highlight in your ministry this year?
What moments have reminded you why you do what you do? Remembering your why is essential.
How have you seen students grow in their faith?

So take time to thank God for the wins. Maybe even shoot a text to a volunteer or student who has made a difference this year.

What This Means for You: Celebrate what God has already done before worrying about what still needs work.

2. Where Have You Felt Stuck or Frustrated?

Every youth pastor has that one thing that just hasn’t been working. Maybe small group engagement has dropped. It’s possible student leadership has struggled. Perhaps you feel like you’re doing too much alone.

Reflection Questions:

What’s not working in your ministry right now? It takes honesty to admit this.
What’s consistently draining your energy?
What patterns or problems keep coming up?

So instead of accepting frustration as normal, identify one specific area to troubleshoot and improve. You don’t have to fix absolutely everything in your mid-year youth ministry review.

What This Means for You: Pinpoint what’s holding you back so you can make necessary adjustments.

3. How Are You Personally Doing in Ministry?

Forget about the mid-year youth ministry assessment for a second. Let’s talk about a mid-year you ministry assessment! It’s easy to focus so much on students that you forget to check in on your own soul.

Reflection Questions:

Are you spiritually healthy right now? Do you feel God’s Spirit alive and at work within you? Are there areas of where you’ve developed an unhealthy dependency as you try to get by?
Are you leading from a place of burnout or joy?
When was the last time you spent time with Jesus for yourself, not just for a lesson?

So if you’re feeling drained, take intentional steps to prioritize your own faith and well-being.

What This Means for You: A healthy youth pastor leads a healthy youth ministry.

4. Are You Making Disciples or Just Running Programs?

It’s easy to get caught up in the logistics of youth ministry. Our role requires us to wear so many different hats, it can be easy to miss the forest for the trees. Assessing this isn’t meant to bring up feelings of inadequacy or shame. It’s meant to keep us aligned with the primary purpose for which we’ve been called—making disciples.

Reflection Questions:

Are students growing in their personal faith? You don’t control this, but your ministry contributes!
Are leaders mentoring and discipling students well?
Are you measuring success by depth, not just numbers?

So shift focus from programming to discipleship. Find ways to make sure students are being shaped spiritually, not just entertained.

What This Means for You: Numbers matter—but real discipleship matters more.

5. What Needs to Change Before Fall?

The school year will be here before you know it. Now is the time to adjust what’s not working so you don’t carry the same struggles into the fall.

Reflection Questions:

What small adjustments would make a big impact? It doesn’t have to be time consuming to be effective.
What’s one leadership or strategy shift that needs to happen?
How can you prepare for the fall before it gets busy?

So make a simple, realistic plan for improvement.

What This Means for You: The second half of the year doesn’t have to look like the first. Make adjustments now.

Final Thought: The Second Half of the Year Is Full of Possibility

It can be emotionally tough to do a mid-year youth ministry check-in. But no matter how the first half of the year went, God isn’t done with your ministry. Celebrate the wins. Identify what’s not working. Check in on your own spiritual health. Focus on making disciples, not just running programs. Adjust now so you’re ready for the fall.

The best youth ministries are willing to reflect, refine, and refocus. Let this mid-year check-in be the push you need to step into the next season with fresh energy and vision.

Related Posts:

📌 How to Prepare for Summer Attendance Drops in Youth Ministry