How To Teach Teenagers About Identity In Christ

Teenagers are sorting through identity all the time, even if they don’t call it that. They’re trying to figure out who they are, how they matter, and where they belong. And the world is more than ready to answer. Social media says identity is how you present yourself. Culture says it’s about achievement, style, or status. Friends say it’s about who accepts you and who doesn’t. But what does God say?

As youth pastors, one of the most important things we can teach is that identity isn’t something we work for. It’s something we receive in Christ. When a student believes that, really believes it, it changes everything. It lifts the pressure. It gives them rest. It anchors them. So how do we teach it in a way that actually sticks?

Start With the Lies

Teenagers rarely show up asking questions about identity. But the lies they believe about who they are show up all the time.

“I’m only valuable if I win.”
“If they don’t like me, something must be wrong with me.”
“If they knew the real me, they wouldn’t love me.”

They might not say it like that. It’s more subtle than that. But if we can show up with ears to hear and eyes to see, we’ll notice their cues. It’s in their decisions. In their silence. In the way they shrink back or puff up. So start there. Ask:

What do you think makes someone valuable?
What do you think God sees when He looks at you?
What voices are the loudest when you’re deciding who you are?

Help students identify the truth and name the lies. The goal isn’t to shame them or make them uncomfortable. It’s just…sometimes the lies we believe sound really, obviously true until we say them out loud to someone else. Hearing ourselves say out loud the thing we quietly believe is true often reveals to us just how clear it is that that belief is a lie.

Let Scripture Do the Heavy Lifting

We say “you’re loved” a lot. And it’s true. But without Scripture, it can land like a compliment instead of a truth that reshapes someone’s soul. So open the Bible with them. Show them where their identity is actually rooted.

You are God’s workmanship. (Ephesians 2:10)
You are fully known and fully loved. (Psalm 139:1–4)
You are His child. (John 1:12)
You are not your past. (2 Corinthians 5:17)
You belong to something eternal. (Philippians 3:20)

Write them down. Read them out loud. Hand them a list. These verses are foundational. In fact, I was in my senior year of high school when I began intentionally memorizing Scripture. Some of these verses, as a result, lay the foundation for my identity and the way I process information and emotions. It’s because early on in my life, I made God’s Word a lamp unto my feet and a light unto my path. We would do our students a great service if we nudged them toward that.

Help Them See the Shift

Most curriculums claim to teach teenagers about identity in Christ. The phrase itself is one of those Christian buzzwords that shows up so frequently, we don’t always have a sharp idea on what it means. But it’s far more than just identifying as a Christian. Placing your identity in Christ means reorienting your entire perception of “me” around the person and work of Jesus. And when we can lead students to do that, they’ll begin realizing things like:

If I’m already loved, I don’t need to perform to be accepted.
If I’m already secure, failure doesn’t get to define me.
If I’m already new, I don’t have to live like I’m still stuck.

Don’t Be Afraid to Push

You’ll hear this from students when you ask about their core beliefs: “Yeah, yeah, I know God loves me.”

And because we’re youth pastors, we’re cool. We don’t nag. We’re not debbie-downers. Youth leaders give kids the benefit of the doubt. So naturally, when a student tells us “I know God loves me,” there’s something inside of many of us who let it go. We know the way they’re saying it suggests they view God’s love as old news, but we don’t want to be overly naggy or preachy, so we just let it go.

To some extent, there’s wisdom in this approach. We don’t have to get on students about every spiritual imperfection every time we see one. God sure as heck doesn’t do that toward us. We’d be completely overwhelmed if He did. So it makes sense that we’d make it a regular rhythm to let students not have every aspect of their relationship with God figured out. But we can also push a little bit from time to time. Every once in a while, it might make sense for you to pull a student aside and tell them “if you knew, like really knew, deep down in your being, that God loves you, you’d live differently.”

I’m just saying. In step with the leading of the Holy Spirit, don’t be afraid to push a little bit when teenagers are clearly believing lies but confessing the truth. You might need to make a relational withdrawal with a kid if you want to teach teenagers about identity in Christ.

Tell the Truth About Your Own Journey

Sharing story is one of the best and most powerful things we can do in a youth ministry environment. Just consider the generational shift that has happened in culture. We went from Millennials worshipping perfect celebrities and high production video content creators to normal everyday people monetizing a TikTok channel where they shoot silly videos in their house on their iPhone. Students value authenticity. They value story.

And you don’t need to tell your whole life story. Just share a moment: When did you feel pressure to be someone else? What lie did you believe about your worth? How did Jesus meet you there?

With this next generation, polished is far less important than real. And when you are, you give your students permission to be real too.

Give Them Something They Can Do

If you’ve ever felt like your students are a bit disengaged during youth group, it’s often because they’re bored. They’re not bored with you. They’re not bored with the lessons, even. It’s more like they’re bored with a faith that doesn’t push them beyond the mundanity of everyday teenage life. In other words, your kids want to do something. Hearing truth is important. Living in it is better. So give them a way to practice.

Take a break from posting and reflect on why it’s hard.
Write a verse about identity on a sticky note and put it on their mirror.
Spend a week encouraging other people instead of seeking validation from them.

When students do something interactive about their faith, it becomes far more real to them. Students are often like spiritual bats. They need other objects to bounce their “sound waves” off of, or else they’re completely lost spiritually. That illustration is incredibly helpful to us as we teach teenagers about identity in Christ.

One More Thing

Teaching identity is a lifelong conversation. And your students will need to hear it again and again. This is why, over again in G Shades Youth Ministry Curriculum, we teach students that:

You are not your success.
You are not your shame.
You are not what others say.
You are in Christ. And that is enough.

If you’re looking for a full series to teach teenagers about identity in Christ, take a look at Hello My Name Is. It’s built to help students discover identity through a gospel lens—and hopefully, through that lens, begin to see clearly.

Related Posts:

Best Curriculum for Youth Pastors
How to Teach Teenagers About Spiritual Habits

We receive a small share of the revenue from any items you purchase from affiliate links in this post.