How To Keep Students Engaged In Small Groups: 5 Strategies That Work

I’m a preacher at heart. I like monologuing. If I said anything different, I’d be lying to you and myself. And sometimes I feel a little bit embarrassed about that. Because while preaching is important, small groups should be one of the most powerful environments in any youth ministry environment. They’re where students go beyond listening to sermons and start wrestling with faith, building relationships, and applying truth to their daily lives.

But here’s the challenge. And this is probably part of why I prefer preaching to running a small group: Some students dominate the conversation. Others barely say a word. Discussions can feel forced, awkward, or disconnected from real life. If small groups feel stale, surface-level, or forced, it’s time to rethink your approach. Here are five practical strategies to keep students engaged in small groups.

1. Make Small Groups a Safe Space for Real Talk

If students don’t feel safe, accepted, or comfortable, they won’t open up. The #1 reason students check out in small groups is fear of judgment—whether from their peers or their leaders. If they think they’ll be laughed at, corrected harshly, or ignored, they’ll stay silent.

How to create a safe space:

• Make openness the norm by sharing personal struggles (within reason). If leaders are real, students will be too.
• Let students say honest, unfiltered thoughts without immediately correcting them. (“I just don’t think prayer really works.” → Instead of shutting it down, explore it with them.)
• Ensure everyone has a voice—don’t let the same two students dominate every week.

When students trust that they can be real without judgment, engagement increases.

2. Move Beyond “Yes or No” Questions

If you want to keep students engaged in small groups, know that one-word answers kill discussion. If every question can be answered with “yes,” “no,” or “Jesus,” students won’t dig deeper.

How to fix this:

• Ask open-ended questions. (“What do you think Jesus meant when He said…?”)
• Use real-life scenarios. (“How would you handle this if it happened at school?”)
• Encourage personal reflection. (“When have you struggled to trust God?”)

Instead of lecturing in small group, ask great questions and let students do the talking.

3. Don’t Be Afraid of Silence

Silence in small groups isn’t always bad—it often means students are actually thinking. But many leaders panic when students don’t answer right away and rush to fill the space. We freak out because the silence makes us question our validity as “good youth leaders.” But that isn’t actually about them. It’s about us. That’s leadership through insecurity, and it actually shuts down deeper responses from students.

How to fix this:

• Invite the Holy Spirit to address your insecurities.
• Give students time. If no one answers immediately, wait 5-10 seconds before moving on.
• Reframe the question if needed. Sometimes students don’t answer because they don’t understand what’s being asked.
• Call on someone gently. If a quiet student hasn’t spoken, try: “Hey, Noah, what do you think?” (Not forcing them, just inviting.)

When students know they won’t be rushed, they’ll think more deeply before they speak.

4. Mix It Up: Small Groups Shouldn’t Just Be Talking

A small group that’s just a long discussion every single week can get predictable and stale. Students learn in different ways. Some process by talking; others need action, movement, or reflection. The last thing we want to do as youth leaders is make small group time so interactive that students don’t actually learn anything. But there’s definitely a middle ground where students learn and connect with one another relationally at the same time.

How to fix this:

Try switching things up by integrating different types of engagement:

• Storytelling: Ask students to share personal experiences related to the topic.
• Object Lessons: Use visuals or activities to reinforce the message.
• Movement-Based Discussions: Have students write down answers and walk around to compare responses.
• Role-Playing: Let students act out different scenarios to practice applying biblical truth.

5. Help Students See Small Group as More Than a Weekly Meeting

If small groups only exist inside church walls, students won’t prioritize them the rest of the week. The goal is for students to see small group as their faith community. And that’s hard to do. You can’t force it. You can’t make them like each other. But the beauty of the gospel is that, in a faith community, we’re bonded over something far stronger than shared interests in sports, fashion, or video games. We’re bonded over grace given us in Christ Jesus. So lean into that (and fun) to help students see small group as more than a weekly meeting.

How to fix this:

• Encourage connections outside of small group. Suggest a group chat, game night, or serving opportunity together.
• Give students challenges to live out. (“Try praying for one friend this week and tell us how it goes.”)
• Celebrate life moments. Birthdays, achievements, even hard days—make it personal.

The more small group feels like family, the more invested students will be.

Small Groups Should Be a Place of Growth

A great small group is where students grow. If students are just going through the motions, something needs to change. But if they’re opening up, asking real questions, and applying faith to life, your small group is doing what it was meant to do. Keep creating a space where students feel safe, challenged, and known—and engagement will follow.

Your ministry thrives when you’re able to keep students engaged in small groups, but the right curriculum plays a major role in creating meaningful discussions. If you’re looking for a curriculum that fosters deeper conversations and keeps students engaged, check out our guide on Choosing The Best Youth Ministry Curriculum For Your Church.

Related Posts:

Best Curriculum for Youth Pastors
Check out Real Friends – a Shop series designed to help students develop authentic, Christ-centered friendships.